BBI P51 Donald Duck for $34.99 + Free Shipping at Target.com
-
- Corporal
- Posts: 33
- Joined: Sun Jul 15, 2007 9:00 pm
- Location: Minnesota USA
BBI P51 Donald Duck for $34.99 + Free Shipping at Target.com
Free shipping is thru tomorrow- So don't dilly daddle!
They also have the F16 on sale for $56 (no free shipping).
Hope this helps,
John
http://www.target.com/Elite-Force-WWII- ... les&page=1
They also have the F16 on sale for $56 (no free shipping).
Hope this helps,
John
http://www.target.com/Elite-Force-WWII- ... les&page=1
-
- Corporal
- Posts: 33
- Joined: Sun Jul 15, 2007 9:00 pm
- Location: Minnesota USA
I have been comparing my new Donald Duck to my 21st Century Big Beautiful Doll.
I'm asking veteran owners of 1/18 P-51s if my evaluation, partly based on other SSHQ comments, in addition to my own, is correct---BBI P-51s are more detailed than 21C P-51s but are less accurate because:
1. Question: Do real P-51s have the large amounts of rivets like BBI's or do real P-51s have smooth surfaces closer to 21C's P-51?
2. The BBI P-51 has inaccurate wing dihedral (which doesn't bother me), landing gear rake problem and wing pylon location.
3. The BBI has antenna wire (which I removed) which some P-51s didn't have.
4. BBI pilot has "US Air Force" on jacket (not US Army Air Force")
5. BBI P-51 has inaccurate, excessive weathering.
However, comparing the BBI P-51 to the 21C P-51, I like the paint scheme of Big Beautiful Doll, but when I hold my BBD, it feels less solid with flopping flaps and wobbling wings (it should have 4 screws, not 2). The BBI P-51 looks much better because of the weathering and when I hold it, it feels more solid and substantial without the shakiness of the 21C P-51.
Bottom line: I wish BBI made its own version of Big Beautiful Doll.
I welcome other comments on the 2 P-51s.
I'm asking veteran owners of 1/18 P-51s if my evaluation, partly based on other SSHQ comments, in addition to my own, is correct---BBI P-51s are more detailed than 21C P-51s but are less accurate because:
1. Question: Do real P-51s have the large amounts of rivets like BBI's or do real P-51s have smooth surfaces closer to 21C's P-51?
2. The BBI P-51 has inaccurate wing dihedral (which doesn't bother me), landing gear rake problem and wing pylon location.
3. The BBI has antenna wire (which I removed) which some P-51s didn't have.
4. BBI pilot has "US Air Force" on jacket (not US Army Air Force")
5. BBI P-51 has inaccurate, excessive weathering.
However, comparing the BBI P-51 to the 21C P-51, I like the paint scheme of Big Beautiful Doll, but when I hold my BBD, it feels less solid with flopping flaps and wobbling wings (it should have 4 screws, not 2). The BBI P-51 looks much better because of the weathering and when I hold it, it feels more solid and substantial without the shakiness of the 21C P-51.
Bottom line: I wish BBI made its own version of Big Beautiful Doll.
I welcome other comments on the 2 P-51s.
-
- Officer - 2nd Lieutenant
- Posts: 255
- Joined: Fri Feb 09, 2007 10:10 pm
- Location: Albany, NY
I have read in a number of posts on this fourm that the BBI Mustang is inaccurate because it is over riveted. However, I sit in a different camp on this issue. I have seen a few wartime color photographs of P-51's which show many rivets.(Something has to hold the plane together!) Here is a link to a wartime factory photo at the World War II in color website: http://www.ww2incolor.com/gallery/homef ... ine?full=1. Question: Do real P-51s have the large amounts of rivets like BBI's or do real P-51s have smooth surfaces closer to 21C's P-51?
If you look at the turned down flaps on the wings of this P-51 you see heavy riveting. Riveting can also be seen on the tail of the Mustang in the foreground. Granted if you have a P-51 in Olive Drab camoflage(Old Crow) the paint would probably fill in/mask the rivets some, but the natural metal mounts that 21st Century has issued, although sleek lack the authentic detail that BBI added. (although I am sure the scale of the rivets on the BBI P-51 could be debated).
On the contrary, Wartime fighters saw a large amount of wear and tear. Based at gloomy fields in England where rain and mud were frequent annoyances.(If you look at the BBI mustangs tires they are muddy.) Combat planes went through a lot of engine strain as well, and would leak oil. Exhaust and gun stains would form quickly as well. A lot of the paint that was applied such as the OD camo and Invasion Stripes were painted with great speed without any primer. They had sloppy edges and quicky would chip and fade.5. BBI P-51 has inaccurate, excessive weathering.
I remember when 21st century used to weather some of their early releases they received criticism about their weathering technique. Roy Sutherland said that it was better to release the model without the weathering, so the collector could custom it, as it would be easier to add weathering than remove it.

MOUNTAIN-MAN:
Thanks for the info.
After I got my Donald Duck, I did several searches on SSHQ about BBI's Killer P-51 and found contradicting replies about riveting and weathering. Late last night I continued to look at more replies and the more I looked at, including yours, the more I feel a lot better about Donald Duck and its authenticity. All I have to do now is relocate the wing pylons.
Thanks again.
Thanks for the info.
After I got my Donald Duck, I did several searches on SSHQ about BBI's Killer P-51 and found contradicting replies about riveting and weathering. Late last night I continued to look at more replies and the more I looked at, including yours, the more I feel a lot better about Donald Duck and its authenticity. All I have to do now is relocate the wing pylons.
Thanks again.
I relocated mine years ago......dragon53 wrote:MOUNTAIN-MAN:
Thanks for the info.
After I got my Donald Duck, I did several searches on SSHQ about BBI's Killer P-51 and found contradicting replies about riveting and weathering. Late last night I continued to look at more replies and the more I looked at, including yours, the more I feel a lot better about Donald Duck and its authenticity. All I have to do now is relocate the wing pylons.
Thanks again.
This is the old position.....

I cut the tab off and glued the pylon back on in the correct position:

Also, if you cut off the center tab on the flaps, they will drop all of the way:

-Ski
[url=http://good-times.webshots.com/photo/2869983520050168193AYuxRR][img]http://inlinethumb18.webshots.com/8785/2869983520050168193S600x600Q85.jpg[/img][/url]
-
- Corporal
- Posts: 33
- Joined: Sun Jul 15, 2007 9:00 pm
- Location: Minnesota USA
Thanks for the awesome pictorial Teamski! As soon as I break "The Duck" out of the package I will do that.
I also broke down and ordered the F-16 today. With a sale price of $56, the 10% off code (thanks dragon 53!), plus a Target gift card for Christmas- I got it for about $40 shipped!
Now, I just gotta figure out where I going to put it. I'm running out of room here
John
I also broke down and ordered the F-16 today. With a sale price of $56, the 10% off code (thanks dragon 53!), plus a Target gift card for Christmas- I got it for about $40 shipped!
Now, I just gotta figure out where I going to put it. I'm running out of room here

John
-
- Corporal
- Posts: 33
- Joined: Sun Jul 15, 2007 9:00 pm
- Location: Minnesota USA
Now on sale for $29.99 !
Just a heads-up that these are now on sale right now for $29.99. Still a great price for under $40 shipped!
John
John