Greatest 1:18 Military Action Figure
-
- Officer - Brigadier General
- Posts: 11239
- Joined: Tue Oct 05, 2004 7:38 pm
- Location: Central California
Greatest 1:18 Military Action Figure
This October will mark the 10th anniversary of the creation of 1:18 military products as 21c debuted their Xtreme Detail XD line in February of 2000 and the first releases hit the shelves at TRU in October of that same year. Since the beginning, action figures have been a crucial part of the 1:18 military lineup, no matter the era depicted. 21c had droves of them, supported by all the great offerings over the years from BBI, Unimax, and others.
So, my question is this:
What is the best 1:18 scale military action figure or figure series?
Now there's obviously a lot of leeway with this query. It could be the most accurate figure, the best articulated, the best looking, the most controversial subject, the most random figure, or whatever. Never mind that we've got dozens to choose from.
Have fun
So, my question is this:
What is the best 1:18 scale military action figure or figure series?
Now there's obviously a lot of leeway with this query. It could be the most accurate figure, the best articulated, the best looking, the most controversial subject, the most random figure, or whatever. Never mind that we've got dozens to choose from.
Have fun
"If you fail to plan, you plan to fail."
Best all-around figures are probably Bbi, their failing was the depressingly one-sidedness of their figure output.
Dragon probably had the best detailed accessories.
I can't say 21st was the best at anything outside of variety. Their BoB stahlhelms were great, the best German helmets produced, unfortunately those helmets and decals didn't survive that wave, i don't think. What's with those terrible 1:6 scale decals towards the end?
Dragon probably had the best detailed accessories.
I can't say 21st was the best at anything outside of variety. Their BoB stahlhelms were great, the best German helmets produced, unfortunately those helmets and decals didn't survive that wave, i don't think. What's with those terrible 1:6 scale decals towards the end?
I Tan I Epi Tas
-
- Officer - Brigadier General
- Posts: 9653
- Joined: Mon Jan 22, 2007 5:52 am
- Location: New Orleans
-
- Officer - 2nd Lieutenant
- Posts: 349
- Joined: Thu Feb 19, 2009 12:45 pm
- Location: So Cal
- Contact:
Dragons look the best and have the best detail though if I were ALLGO I would model mine after Hasbros GiJoe line. They have the best articulation of any 1/18 action figure line ..... just a hint ALLGO ... drop the crappy articulation and shoddy detail of the old 21C figures and start freash.
USMC CHET
John P. Hermesmeyer
92-96 5th Marines 0311
Semper Fi
John P. Hermesmeyer
92-96 5th Marines 0311
Semper Fi
-
- Officer - Brigadier General
- Posts: 6374
- Joined: Fri Mar 21, 2008 3:16 pm
- Location: Orlando FL
I have to go with.
Dragon German & American Figures
21st Japanese Figures
The Schutzstaffel Set
21st Fallschirmjagers
BBI Figures
FOV German & American Figures
Dragon German & American Figures
21st Japanese Figures
The Schutzstaffel Set
21st Fallschirmjagers
BBI Figures
FOV German & American Figures
The mind is the limit. As long as the mind can envision the fact that you can do something, you can do it, as long as you really believe 100 percent.
-
- Officer - Captain
- Posts: 835
- Joined: Sun Mar 09, 2008 3:49 pm
Hmm,
This is a tough question, since you have to take a little from each line to truly make an Ultimate action figure.
I'd have to say for a stand alone figure. BBIs last series of Paras was the best in terms of versatility and detail. Although the undersized helmets and heads were a little disapointing.
This is a tough question, since you have to take a little from each line to truly make an Ultimate action figure.
I'd have to say for a stand alone figure. BBIs last series of Paras was the best in terms of versatility and detail. Although the undersized helmets and heads were a little disapointing.
figs
Here is an old comparison photo I have of three 101st from each company. The heads and helmets are all bbi (great heads and usually a very easy swap). Btw, Dragon had the best guns but some awful helmets and big heads.
-
- Officer - Brigadier General
- Posts: 11239
- Joined: Tue Oct 05, 2004 7:38 pm
- Location: Central California
In my opinion, BBI had the best figures all around, with their WWII D-Day troops and paratroopers being my favorites.
For the best figure line, I really enjoyed the 21c Marines. The articulation was not the best, but they were sculpted well and the faces had character without being too cartoonish. Following this theme, my favorite 1:18 action figure is probably the 21c USMC Series 1 Sgt. Digger McHugh figure. Holding that Japanese flag, the rifle, and with that scowl, he looks like he just took out an entire Japanese platoon on his own, actually earning the "Ultimate Soldier" title on his cardback
As for sheer randomness, I think the Flight 19 aliens fit the bill
For the best figure line, I really enjoyed the 21c Marines. The articulation was not the best, but they were sculpted well and the faces had character without being too cartoonish. Following this theme, my favorite 1:18 action figure is probably the 21c USMC Series 1 Sgt. Digger McHugh figure. Holding that Japanese flag, the rifle, and with that scowl, he looks like he just took out an entire Japanese platoon on his own, actually earning the "Ultimate Soldier" title on his cardback
As for sheer randomness, I think the Flight 19 aliens fit the bill
"If you fail to plan, you plan to fail."
Dragon figs are my favorites. Some of the German heads are a bit silly looking though.
21C Marines have the best head sculpts IMO.
21C FJ's rank near the top since no other company ever attempted German paras. We have 6 in 1:18...end of story.
BBI paras are amazing, but they are a bit fragile. I have broken more than one of these guys just trying to remove some equipment or twist a wrist.
21C Marines have the best head sculpts IMO.
21C FJ's rank near the top since no other company ever attempted German paras. We have 6 in 1:18...end of story.
BBI paras are amazing, but they are a bit fragile. I have broken more than one of these guys just trying to remove some equipment or twist a wrist.
B/S/T Contacts:holensock,billgiff,Razor17019,KWR190,ostketten,kevrut,ram04 etc...
-
- Officer - Brigadier General
- Posts: 3484
- Joined: Wed Oct 06, 2004 11:37 am
- Location: Pittsburgh, PA
- Contact:
Every series has its flaws...
-BBI... Their hands weren't always great for posing with the weaponry, their helmets I find a tad small, and most of their gear wasn't removable or it left phantom straps and gaping holes in the backs.
-FOV... All the gear comes off nice, and I think their Germans are among the best figures out there, but their US uniforms weren't accurate. Different color on those coats and lose the big pockets on the pants, and their US figures would be better.
-Dragon... Awesome sculpting detail, awesome weapons, but zero articulation. Fun to pose around artillery or something, but that's about it to me. They're mostly good for filler and extra gear.
-21st... They made the most, their gear was the least offensive when it was removed, but their paintjobs were iffy, sculpts varied with each wave from great to pure crap, and so on.
So...
For pure sculpt, my vote goes to BBI.
For articulation I would say my vote is tied between FOV, 21st, and BBI. I think all 3 are great and fun.
For deco, my vote goes to FOV and BBI as 21st was too spotty with theirs... Some waves were good, others not so good.
For accessories, my vote goes to FOV (all the gear BBI figures had + usually better looking IMO, + it didn't leave gaping holes or phantom straps and things). Dragon's a close second but they were pricey figures at the onset too, so I prefer the FOV figures there.
Overall I really can't say I have a favorite... I love BBI, 21st, and FOV for a variety of different reasons and would love to buy more figures from each company. I'd buy from Dragon too, but they really needed to try harder to make an action figure and less to make a model. Difficult for a model company to do though of course.
For great figures though, some of my favorite series have been:
-21st's BotB series
-21st's Fal's
-21st's D-Day series (the last waves of figures)
-BBI's full removable gear paratroopers
-BBI's D-Day guys
-FOV's WW2 figures
-BBI... Their hands weren't always great for posing with the weaponry, their helmets I find a tad small, and most of their gear wasn't removable or it left phantom straps and gaping holes in the backs.
-FOV... All the gear comes off nice, and I think their Germans are among the best figures out there, but their US uniforms weren't accurate. Different color on those coats and lose the big pockets on the pants, and their US figures would be better.
-Dragon... Awesome sculpting detail, awesome weapons, but zero articulation. Fun to pose around artillery or something, but that's about it to me. They're mostly good for filler and extra gear.
-21st... They made the most, their gear was the least offensive when it was removed, but their paintjobs were iffy, sculpts varied with each wave from great to pure crap, and so on.
So...
For pure sculpt, my vote goes to BBI.
For articulation I would say my vote is tied between FOV, 21st, and BBI. I think all 3 are great and fun.
For deco, my vote goes to FOV and BBI as 21st was too spotty with theirs... Some waves were good, others not so good.
For accessories, my vote goes to FOV (all the gear BBI figures had + usually better looking IMO, + it didn't leave gaping holes or phantom straps and things). Dragon's a close second but they were pricey figures at the onset too, so I prefer the FOV figures there.
Overall I really can't say I have a favorite... I love BBI, 21st, and FOV for a variety of different reasons and would love to buy more figures from each company. I'd buy from Dragon too, but they really needed to try harder to make an action figure and less to make a model. Difficult for a model company to do though of course.
For great figures though, some of my favorite series have been:
-21st's BotB series
-21st's Fal's
-21st's D-Day series (the last waves of figures)
-BBI's full removable gear paratroopers
-BBI's D-Day guys
-FOV's WW2 figures
http://www.JediDefender.com Bringing Balance to the Force
http://www.FFURG.com The Ultimate Customizing Resource.
Now Hasbro, make us some Head Sculpt & Endor Uniform variations! The new Rebel Fleet Trooper gets the JJ Seal of Approval Though!
http://www.FFURG.com The Ultimate Customizing Resource.
Now Hasbro, make us some Head Sculpt & Endor Uniform variations! The new Rebel Fleet Trooper gets the JJ Seal of Approval Though!